I’m Not There

Last night I finally got a chance to see I’m Not There. As an on again off again unpredictable but rampant Bob Dylan fan, I was bound to like the movie more than most. Because without the background knowledge of other Dylan iconography, it’s hard to get a handle on the pastiche presented in Todd Hayne’s latest work. Like watching Velvet Goldmine without any knowledge of glam rock or David Bowie, or Far From Heaven before seeing anything by Douglas Sirk (two things I’ve been known to do), these movies are best experienced on multiple planes of recognition.

I'm not there

That’s not to say that I’m Not There can’t be enjoyed by someone who hasn’t read the biographies, seen the documentaries, or even listened to the music. On the surface, I’m Not There functions as an interesting rock-biopic with fabulous performances (Cate Blanchett put a sock in her pants so she could walk like a dude). But, I think, it’s the recognition of the various levels of pastiche that offers a viewer that deeper enjoyability. Probably self-congratulatory, but in the way that I love to be congratulated by myself.

Okay, so each story is representative of a different persona that Dylan either alluded to or adopted (my favorite is the inclusion of Christian Dylan played by Christian Bale. Get it??). And then each film style that each Dylan operates in is representative of a different period of Dylan’s life and the ways in which he was represented in those periods. So the Dylan that Cate Blanchett plays, as a character called Jude Quinn (a reference I still haven’t pinned down), is shot in the exact way that D.A. Pennebaker shoots Dylan in his observational documentary Dont Look Back, with hand held cameras, black and white footage, and unpredictable edits. (My favorite example of this is when Haynes shoots representations of the Beatles fooling around in fast-motion, exactly like my favorite scene in Hard Days Night.)

bob dylan dont look back

Still from Dont Look Back. I think they should have kept the apostrophe out of I’m Not There, too.

i'm not there

BUT, the music doesn’t correspond with each Dylan. Jack Rollins (Christian Bale) plays “The Lonesome Death of Hattie Carroll” for migrant workers, evoking the same shot seen in Dont Look Back of a concert in the late 50s, before Hattie Carroll was even killed in 1963. Similarly, Dylan’s love life is liberally sprinkled throughout the film, with Joan Baez’s representation (named “Alice Fabean” and played by Julianne Moore) situated chronologically before Dylan’s girlfriend Suze Rotolo (named “Claire” in the film and played by Charlotte Gainsbourge) who is shown walking down the street in the same pose as the Freewheelin’ cover.

freewheelin bob dylan album cover

There are pieces that don’t seem to fit so closely. For example, Billy the Kid (Richard Gere) is another reincarnation of Dylan, but in an early time. This might be a reference to Dylan’s small part in Sam Peckinpah’s Pat Garrett and Billy the Kid, or it might just refer to Dylan’s admiration of the Kid specifically and American outlaws in general. The style in this segment is more carnivalesque (it is, after all, Halloween in the small down where the Kid is living) than old-west, though, which breaks from Haynes other fidelity to other decades presented.
christian bale i'm not there

bob dylan

I guess I could go on all day, trying to uncover the various references and pastiche. It’s hard for me to predict whether or not a non-Dylan fan would enjoy I’m Not There, because I’m obviously so entrenched in the mythology of Dylan as an American character. I’m inclined to believe that the film still packs an emotional punch, even if you aren’t a huge fan. Just as Dylan’s music can appeal to a wide variety of people – especially when you consider his multiple styles that he has embraced over the years – I think the film can capture the attention of those who are willing to sit through an attempt to translate poetry to images. This film seems more of an aesthetic effort than any sort of accurate portrayal, and I really appreciate the effort. There are moments that are, perhaps, ill fitting, and, likewise, moments that conform too much to the genre conventions of a biopic. However, it is the often tragic and always interesting presence of Dylan himself (through references and music) that prove the backbone of this film and what, I think, make it the most beautiful documentation of his life.



Filed under Whitney

4 responses to “I’m Not There

  1. chandelle

    oooh…i definitely want to see this one. i’m an erratic and rampant dylan fan as well. cate blanchett is wildly beautiful, and dylan was wildly beautiful in his youth, and so cate as dylan? pure bliss.

  2. The only real exposure I had had with Bob Dylan before watching this movie came from “Dangerous Minds,” the LouAnne Johnson biopic in which the songs of Bob Dylan are compared to the poems of Dylan Thomas in the notorious Dylan-Dylan contest. Of course, Callie and Raul go on to win the contest but when Callie has to work the night of the reward (a fancy dinner with Mrs. Johnson) only Raul can come. He buys a stolen jacket which Mrs. Johnson must loan him the money for so that he won’t go out and skip class to steal the money. She makes him promise to pay her back on the day he graduates. When it turns out that she is going to leave to teach somewhere else, Raul asks her how he’s to keep is promise? She ends up staying on as a teacher and serving as inspiration to other teachers who had given up on these minority students, the children looking to her for guidance, and all the naysayers who said ‘nay’ to her. That’s was my experience with Bob Dylan before watching “I’m Not There.”

    Now I know more.

  3. Also…I really love the song “Mr. Tambourine Man.”

  4. theinfj

    Just finished Dylan’s Chronicales and watched I’m Not There. Thanks for this thoughtful post and the comparison photos. Really interesting.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s